Council voted for additional cost saving measures to be reviewed following community feedback on proposed rate rises.

The final Northern Beaches Council meeting of the year (Tuesday, 10 December) became a focus for community concern about proposed rate rises, with five residents speaking against the proposed rises.

Newport resident Frank Peylaire (main image, third from right) challenged the arguments Council had made in its community consultations.

“I am an advisor to state agencies, specialised in developing economic and financial justifications for multibillion dollar projects. I will present a few simple financial concepts to demonstrate that none of the four rate variation options will save the council.

“The three former councils’ — Manly, Pittwater, Warringah — total expenditure was $308m in 2016. The Northern Beaches Council total expenditure was $398m in 2024.

“That is $90m more than eight years ago, almost $1,000 more per dwelling every year. This is an average increase of 3.3 percent each year since amalgamation, above the annual average inflation for the same period.

“Staff costs have surged from $120m in 2016 to $159m in 2024, close to $40m more than eight years ago. This is an average increase of 3.5 percent each year since amalgamation, above the 2.5 percent annual average wage growth for the same period.

“Most of the increase happened before the [COVID-19] pandemic and in the last two years. The council financials are out of control. It is facing a diseconomy of scale, the contrary of economy of scale. It is too big to be sustainable.

“The amalgamation has produced no efficiency, no productivity gain whatsoever. Ironically, the Council is unfit for the future, when this was the key argument of the amalgamation reform.

“Some say that the former Pittwater Council had a lot of debt that the Northern Beaches Council had to deal with. Would you wish to inherit a $3m house with a $2m mortgage? What if the house also had a safe with another $3m cash in it? That’s Pittwater in 2016.

“Pittwater had a total debt of $23.8m against cash in bank of $44m, that’s $20.2m cash net of debt. That’s not all, there was another $7.8m to be received from rates and grants net of payables.

“In total Pittwater had $28m in liquid assets, net of debt. So why are we only hearing about the debt of Pittwater? $15.7m of this cash was from restricted developer contributions to fund developments. Net of these contributions, $12.3m was sitting in banks, unrestricted, readily available cash ‘in the safe’.

“Where did the cash of Pittwater go? How could ratepayers believe that this council can be fixed with more money?” asked Mr Peylaire.

Councillors were later told that comparisons with figures from the 2016 year of amalgamation were not correct, because the amalgamation happened ten months through a financial year. Mr Peylaire has since clarified to Councillors that his numbers were annualised to take this into account.

Mr Peylaire’s speech set the tone for debate on the motion for the special rate variation, and appeared to reflect a mood that was being expressed to Councillors outside the Chamber.

Candy Bingham

Debate broke into two broad camps, the first reflected in a motion put forward by Cr Candy Bingham (image above), that the factors driving the need for increases needed further explanation; and the second reflected in an amendment moved by Cr Vincent De Luca OAM, that Council needed to do more work on finding ways to save money.

Cr Bingham congratulated Council staff on the professional way in which community consultation had been undertaken.

“I spent about an hour going through the material, and there was a lot of it. Hundreds of pages, it was all there if you had the time and interest to read through it.

“I did the calculator for my address and that worked very well. It was quite by accident I scrolled to the bottom of the page and found the section called ‘Our work to find savings’.

“Council has done the work, we have saved millions. $26m a year in merger savings alone. Everyone has an idea on how we should save money, but often they don’t know the facts.

“So for the next step in the process, I would like to see a message that simply focuses on what we have done and what we need in the future. In other words, how we tightened our belts, what we have done to save money.

“People don’t want to pay more in rates until the reason why is explained to them. We have to do all we can to ensure our community is well-informed. A simple one page summary as to what we have done to tighten our belts will go a long way to resolve this issue,” said Cr Bingham.

Councillor Vincent De Luca OAM

Cr Vincent De Luca (image above) moved an amendment which included Cr Bingham’s request for more information, but said that more work was needed to find ways to cut costs.

“If we go to the meeting in January [2025] without this information, we are missing an opportunity to make real change and are also not ensuring transparency and good governance.

“It is overwhelmingly clear from our community they want information and they want action taken that could avert the various options that propose rate increases.

“In any event, unless option four were to be adopted, we would still have to find money, and a lot of it,” said Cr De Luca.

Ethan Hrnjak launches Greens campaign for Forest ward

Cr De Luca found support from The Greens Councillor Ethan Hrnjak (image above), who called the amendment a ‘second chance’ to be transparent.

“Given the numerous community requests we have had for this information and for real action to demonstrate how serious we are about the current financial position of Council, I feel like this is a second chance to be transparent with the community,” said Cr Hrnjak.

Cr Bingham said it was ‘too late’ for other options to be considered.

“It’s too late. We have had all the opportunities to do all these things. We’ve been saving money for eight years since the amalgamation. I don’t think getting a whole lot of reports at the last minute will change anything,” warned Cr Bingham.

Despite concerns that additional reports on cost reduction measures may not find the savings necessary to avert rate rises, Cr De Luca’s amendment was ultimately carried and voted through.

An extraordinary meeting of Council will be called for Tuesday, 28 January 2025, and Councillors will now receive a report a week beforehand that outlines ways in which cost reductions may be achieved.

Further, Cr De Luca’s motion obligates Council to write to all local Members of Parliament, raising concerns over the lack of grant funding being given to the Northern Beaches.

Northern Beaches Council is running a comprehensive public awareness campaign that provides detail on the reasons behind the need for a special rate variation, savings Council has made, additional fund-raising efforts and what each of the four options means in terms of services.

Our previous article covers these options, but we recommend people review Council’s information to be further informed on the basis Council is seeking a special rate variation. Submissions close Sunday, 12 January 2025.

Images: Northern Beaches Advocate

Editorial note: Public submissions opened Monday, 18 November 2024. At the time of writing, Northern Beaches Council had received 3,440 submissions.

Northern Beaches Advocate email newsletter

What did you miss this week?

Get the week's news delivered free to your inbox every Saturday. Subscribe to our free email newsletter.