A curious political combination formed on Council in an attempt to block proposals to increase rates by up to 46 percent.

In an unusual turn of events at last week’s Northern Beaches Council meeting (Tuesday, 12 November), The Greens Councillors backed Independent Councillors Vincent De Luca OAM, Bob Giltinan OAM and Sunny Singh in a call for Council to find ways to cut costs before a special rate increase is considered.

They were overruled by Your Northern Beaches Independent team (YNBIT) Councillors however, who felt Cr De Luca was too selective in where he had asked for a review of Council’s costs.

Northern Beaches Council has found itself in a budget squeeze, after years of bonanza grant funding for projects, the NSW Government has tightened the purse strings. Council says that combined with budget pressure from increased costs, COVID-19, natural disasters and worn out assets, a special rate variation is required to avoid cuts to services.

Council has put forward four proposals for community consultation, which range from ‘do nothing’ to ‘do more’:

  1. No special increase. Increase rates by only the Independent Pricing and Regulatory Tribunal (IPART) annual rate peg of approximately 10.7 percent (average residential rate rise of $181) over the next three years. Council says it will be forced to cut services under this scenario.
  2. Maintain services. Increase rates by 31.1 percent (average residential rate rise of $527) over three years. Council says this will raise $40m over the three years to address asset renewal and maintenance gaps.
  3. Increase service. Increase rates by 39.6 percent (average residential rate rise of $673) over three years. Council says this will raise $57m over the three years allowing for renewal of larger assets such as Warringah Aquatic Centre, which is currently unfunded.
  4. Accelerate delivery. Increase rates by 46 percent (average residential rate rise of $780) over three years. Council says this will raise $69m over the three years allowing for increased services and accelerated delivery of capital works, including footpaths and sporting facilities.

Rate rises for businesses will be between two to three times higher than those of residential properties under the various options, reflecting the higher rates that businesses pay.

Councillor Vincent De Luca OAM

Cr De Luca (image above) warned that Council needed to find savings as the promise of a merged Council had failed to sufficiently deliver to residents.

“We need to look our community in the eye and say we have considered every possible alternative before we commit to a special rate variation. Unless Council adopts option 4, we will still have to look at funding opportunities. It is good governance for us to look within [for savings].

“This is not a fait accompli. I want to look at alternatives other than slapping a maximum special rate rise application [on residents]. Prior to amalgamation, correspondence was sent out by the former Mayor, saying unless we amalgamated, rates would go up.

“The CEO has inherited a mess, we have never had it disclosed, like he has, the financial situation we are in. That is why we have to lead by example and wherever possible, investigate alternatives. If [option] 1, 2 or 3 is passed, we still have to find funding,” said Cr De Luca.

Ethan Hrnjak launches Greens campaign for Forest ward

The Greens Councillor Ethan Hrnjak (image above) supported Cr De Luca’s request for options to cut spending, saying the community was suffering from the increased cost of living.

“Our community is suffering a cost of living crisis, which Council is not immune to. A report on how funding could be prioritised would show the community we are doing everything we can to address the situation we find ourselves in as a Council,” said Cr Hrnjak.

Sarah Grattan

YNBIT Councillor Sarah Grattan (image above) said that while there were cost of living pressures impacting the community, there were also expectations of Council that need to be met.

“We know we have been living through a very high inflationary period, particularly for construction and civil engineering. The Local Government Award impact on wages and salaries has been well in excess of our rate cap. It’s not surprising we have this growing gap between our revenue and the cost of delivery.

“We can’t be cutting tea and biscuits to find $40m to fund the aspiration at the higher level. We need to consult the community about the level of service that is required. People are struggling, particularly people with a mortgage.

“But we are also hearing from the community we need upgraded change rooms, surf clubs, roads fixed, parks maintained. They don’t want to have to cut Christmas to do it, or not have New Year’s fireworks, or close swimming facilities because we can’t afford to fix them,” said Cr Grattan.

Community consultation sessions will also be held across the Northern Beaches at the following dates and locations:

  • 8.00am to 12.00pm Friday, 22 November — Beaches Farmers Market, Narrabeen (Rat Park)
  • 10.15am to 12.45pm Saturday, 23 November — Forestville Shopping Centre
  • 8.00am to 11.15am Sunday, 24 November — Manly Fresh Produce Markets, Sydney Road, Manly
  • 9.45am to 12.15pm Wednesday, 27 November — Balgowlah Village Shopping Centre (Stockland Mall)
  • 10.15am to 12.45pm Thursday, 28 November — Walter Gors Park, Dee Why
  • 9.45am to 12.15pm Saturday, 30 November — Freshwater Village
  • 9.15am to 11.45am Saturday, 30 November — Mona Vale Memorial Hall
  • 9.45am to 12.15pm Thursday, 05 December — Forest Way Shopping Centre
  • 9.15am to 11.45am Friday, 06 December — Avalon Woolworths
  • 9.00am to 1.15pm Sunday, 15 December — Berry Reserve Markets, Narrabeen

Additional online information sessions will be held from 2.00pm to 3.30pm Monday, 02 December, and 7.00pm to 8.30pm Wednesday, 11 December.

To find out more about the special rate variation and make a submission, visit the Your Say website. Submissions close Sunday, 12 January 2025.

Images: Envato, Northern Beaches Advocate

Editorial note: Submissions opened Monday, 18 November 2024. At the time of writing, Northern Beaches Council had received 78 submissions.

Northern Beaches Advocate email newsletter

What did you miss this week?

Get the week's news delivered free to your inbox every Saturday. Subscribe to our free email newsletter.