Councillors have voted to condemn the NSW Government for ‘unfair attacks’ on the Northern Beaches.

Vincent De Luca

Vincent De Luca

A motion brought to last week’s meeting (Tuesday, 06 August) of Northern Beaches Council by Narrabeen Ward Councillor Vincent De Luca OAM said the NSW Government should be condemned for ‘its unfair attacks, neglect and funding cuts on the Northern Beaches’.

Cr De Luca’s motion requires Council write to NSW Premier Chris Minns demanding he ‘show fairness and restore funding, services and infrastructure to the Northern Beaches’.

The motion noted the following evidence of ‘neglect and attacks on the Northern Beaches by the State Government’:

  • The State Government is considering that tolls should be higher and that drivers be charged in both directions for crossing the Sydney Harbour Bridge and Tunnel
  • The State Government continue to withhold funding to finish essential Mona Vale Road works
  • The State Government has abandoned the Northern Beaches Tunnel project
  • The State Government has announced the closure of Narrabeen Ambulance Station
  • In July 2023, the State Government reduced bus services on the Northern Beaches without any community consultation
  • The State Government has presided over funding and staff cuts at Northern Beaches Hospital
  • The State Government abandoned plans to upgrade and refurbish Balgowlah Boys High School
  • The State Government had failed to commit to the ongoing funding and support of the Dalwood Spilstead Service [Seaforth]
  • The State Government has announced proposed planning reforms to increase development on the Northern Beaches, despite our community lacking the infrastructure to cope with current development
  • On 20 September 2023, Premier Chris Minns, in Parliament accused the Northern Beaches of ‘NIMBYism’ and targeted and named the suburbs of ‘Bilgola Plateau, Ingleside, Mona Vale, Newport, Palm Beach, Terrey Hills and Warriewood’
The Greens Councillor Miranda Korzy

With the 2024 NSW Local Government elections looming, the motion exposed fault lines and was hotly debated in the Council Chamber. The Greens Councillor Miranda Korzy (image above) acknowledged the Northern Beaches had been disadvantaged but refused to vote for the motion while it contained certain elements.

“There is nothing to support some of these claims. Whilst I absolutely condemn a lot of the moves by the State Government that have reduced funding for projects on the Northern Beaches, I don’t think this approach is the most useful one to take.

“There are points in here that are begging questions and other points I simply cannot support. In Pittwater there is a very large percentage of the population that did not support the Northern Beaches Tunnel. It was going to increase the number of cars we have on the Northern Beaches.

“The Narrabeen Ambulance Station was the former Coalition Government that decided to replicate the Narrabeen Ambulance Station at Mona Vale Hospital. That was a clear waste of money. Why keep Narrabeen Ambulance Station open?

“The Coalition Government closed two hospitals on the Northern Beaches and opened the Northern Beaches Hospital with fewer beds than the two existing hospitals. There are still wards in the new hospital that have never opened. We would be better working with the Labor Government to get the medical care there we need,” said Cr Korzy.

Your Northern Beaches Independent Team (YNBIT) Councillor Sarah Grattan acknowledged the merit of some of the items on the list, but declined to support the motion, saying it was ‘too political’.

Liberal Councillor Karina Page

Liberal Councillor Karina Page (image above), who will be standing against Cr De Luca in Narrabeen Ward at the upcoming elections, nonetheless supported the motion strongly.

“The detailed list of issues presented highlights a pattern of neglect and unfair treatment that our community has endured.

“The proposal to increase tolls and charge drivers in both directions for crossing the Sydney Harbour Bridge and Tunnel is not only a financial burden on our residents but also an inequitable measure that disproportionately affects those who rely on these routes for daily commutes.

“This is just another way to gouge residents of the Northern Beaches. The Beaches don’t have rail or light rail as do other areas. We have limited public transport options compared with the rest of Sydney.

“The abandonment of funding for the essential Mona Vale Road works and the Northern Beaches Tunnel project underscores a significant disregard for critical infrastructure that is vital for the safety and efficiency of our transport network. These projects are not mere conveniences, they are essential for the well-being and economic stability of our region.

“The closure of the Narrabeen Ambulance Station, along with the reduction in bus services without any community consultation, poses severe risks to the health and mobility of our residents.

“The funding and staff cuts at Northern Beaches Hospital, the abandonment of upgrades at Balgowlah Boys High School, and the failure to commit to the Dalwood Spilstead Service reveal a troubling trend in the State Government’s approach to essential services.

“The proposed planning reforms to increase development without adequate infrastructure further exacerbate the challenges we face. Our community is already struggling with the current development levels, and any increase without proper support will lead to unsustainable living conditions.

“Premier Chris Minns’ accusations of ‘NIMBYism’ and the targeting of specific suburbs in Parliament is a divisive and unfair characterisation of our community. It undermines the genuine concerns of residents who are advocating for sustainable and responsible development,” said Cr Page.

The vote split largely along party lines, with the Liberals, supported by Independent Councillors Vincent De Luca and Jose Menano-Pires, narrowly carrying the motion 6-5 against The Greens and YNBIT Councillors. Council will now be required to write to Premier Minns accordingly.

The 2024 NSW Local Government elections will be held on Saturday, 14 September. Pre-poll for the elections will be available for one week, from Saturday, 07 September to Friday, 13 September.

Images: NSW Government, Northern Beaches Advocate

Northern Beaches Advocate email newsletter

What did you miss this week?

Get the week's news delivered free to your inbox every Saturday. Subscribe to our free email newsletter.